I don't think you are being fair in the news section. You are giving exposure to games you prefer. And not always based on quality. I mean, it's your site. I'm just saying it's not fair.
<a href="http://lachie.phatcode.net">The Maker Of Stuff</a>
How about this: You DC- Mail an adminstrator to show up your game on the frontpage if you think your game is good enough. But wait, isn't that thing already availible?
I think it's because they don't see all the good games out there. They just put up the good games that they do see. So it's subject to bias from rumors, screenshots, hype, size, free time, etc.
Of course, the mighty Admin King, ShadowCaster once said that all those games with a good description and a screenshot should be on the front page, but do the little admins follow? Only if they feel like it.
Disclaimer: Any sarcasm in my posts will not be mentioned as that would ruin the purpose. It is assumed that the reader is intelligent enough to tell the difference between what is sarcasm and what is not.
everyone thinks their games are good enough, when truthfully, they aren't.
gone fishin'
Pete Nattress Cheesy Bits img src/uploads/sccheesegif
Registered 23/09/2002
Points 4811
28th January, 2004 at 13:02:16 -
if we put every single game possible on the frontpage it would damage the novelty of it a bit. and then people could post a description and screenshot for a really crap game and by that definition it would have to go up.
If you feel that a game is really great but has been ignored, why don't you dc-mail an admin? I'd hope that they would actually have a look at it, but generally good games have at least two screenshots and a reasonable description. Downloads like that usually make the front page anyway...
Well my downloads here always feature screenshots and more that decent descriptions. And I got solid reviews of my games on other sites. I was a bit surprised Ball Blazing Fantasy got ignored since it is a TOP DOG and HOTU and it got 8/10 at GameHippo. I won't mention other reviews of it in QBasic community since I know you don't give shit about QBasic community.
DC the admin seems like pestering. But then again, I just did that with this post. Crap.
<a href="http://lachie.phatcode.net">The Maker Of Stuff</a>
IMHO, HOTU probably has a contract with Clickteam to give undeserved uber-high reviews on Click game. Either that or the people who designed the games wrote reviews for their own game.
Have you seen FactorX??? That game got a friggin hot dog rating, when I've seen far better games with lower ratings. FactorX was something with a lot of effort into it, true, but it was helluva sloppy and hardly even fun.
And then there's The Spirit Engine. Don't get me wrong, it's a good game, but the description exaggerates it waaaaaaaay too much. "The quality of graphics, soundtrack, and unique gameplay combined make The Spirit Engine one of the highest quality freeware games ever made, and as a bonus it will take you quite a while to finish." *gag*
Sure, TSE is superb by klik standards, but I've seen much better games on HOTU that deserves better ratings. I only found that the graphics on the first few parts to be worthy of such exceptional praise. And the gameplay just got dull and repetitive after a few levels.
In other words, I consider any reviews on Click games on HOTU far less seriously than I consider the Grammys. Same goes with GameHippo.
No offense meant of course, my dear Lachie. It's just that although your references are famous, they just plain suck. I agree that if you were to be mentioned on such sites, you should at least be on the front page of TDC.
Disclaimer: Any sarcasm in my posts will not be mentioned as that would ruin the purpose. It is assumed that the reader is intelligent enough to tell the difference between what is sarcasm and what is not.
TDC is different to most community sites in that the main pages features game submissions by its members. Occasionally, news is posted out of the klik world, but lets face it - we have Klik Academy, Klik-Me, Total Klik to deal with collecting news. If all community sites were like that, then you'd get a bit bored of flicking between them all and finding out they have the same news articles on the front page.
So thats why we generally include stuff sent by you lot. And yes, we are willing to put games on the front page, on the basis that they include at least one of the following:
a. they look good
b. the concept is new
c. it isn't a demo
d. it isnt hosted by some rubbish server
e. it DOES have screenshots
f. it DOES have a good description
g. admins are NOT asked to put it on the front page
h. its actually a KLIK game, and not a darkbasic thing
And regarding what Pete Mattress said - if all the games submitted at DC were on the front page, then there'd be little point to having a main page. Rubbish games will most likely not stand a chance of getting on the main page, but we probably would feature at least average games, which show great potential. And definately we'd feature hyped games, and good games. Its the way of the world, you see.
Just like games magazines. Their main review.. the BIG game of the month is featured, and it usually gets the highest score. The rest of the games don't get mentioned on the front page, and they are consigned to single, or half pages near the back of the magazine. Its just life dude.
Advertisement
Post Reply
.
